On this page
- Top 5 SEO agencies in New York at a glance
- How we picked these agencies
- 1. Rankstar: why it leads this list
- All 16 SEO agencies in New York compared
- The agencies in detail
- SEO in New York: what to know in 2027
- How much does an SEO agency cost in New York?
- How to choose an SEO agency in New York
- SEO agencies in New York: FAQ
- SEO agencies in other US states
This page is for New York businesses choosing an SEO agency, from Manhattan and Brooklyn to Westchester and Long Island.
We compared 16 agencies: 15 with a New York office and a website we confirmed live, plus our own. Data comes from Clutch and agency websites, checked in November 2026. Rankstar, listed first, is our own agency. The others follow a fixed rule explained below.
Top 5 SEO agencies in New York at a glance
| # | Agency | Best for | Clutch | Based in |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Rankstar Our agency | SEO, AEO & GEO, Autosuggest, reputation | — | New York · Paris |
| 2 | DiscoverMyBusinessdiscovermybusiness.co | SEO plus reputation management | ★ 5.0137 reviews | New York |
| 3 | Bird Marketingbird.marketing | Reviewed SEO at mid-level budgets | ★ 5.075 reviews | New York |
| 4 | Web Tonicwebtonic.io | SEO/GEO plus paid media | ★ 5.057 reviews | New York |
| 5 | OpenMovesopenmoves.com | Paid media plus SEO, eCommerce | ★ 5.052 reviews | Huntington |
No agency matches.
How we picked these agencies
Rankstar is listed first because it is our agency. Every other agency had to have a headquarters or confirmed office in New York State and a website that answered when we checked in November 2026. Three sites blocked our checker, but each has a current Clutch profile, so we kept them.
We order agencies by number of Clutch reviews, most first. Agencies without a Clutch profile follow in alphabetical order. Ironpaper sits last because its site lists B2B marketing, not SEO as a service.
We removed agencies from the previous edition that we could not verify, whose sites were unreachable, or whose address was elsewhere. Examples: Breakline (UK address), Jives Media (California), Searchbloom (Utah), and agencies with no address we could find. Clutch figures are provider-reported and change.
1. Rankstar: why it leads this list
- Priced packages. SEO · AEO · GEO packages start at €480 a month, with every item listed on the price page.
- Local search. Local SEO · AEO · GEO packages add Google Business Profile optimisation, also from €480 a month.
- Your brand in the search box. Google Autosuggest from €590 a month for 3 keywords. Negative suggestions removed, usually in 10–20 days, plus reputation management plans.
- An in-house team since 2018. 30+ employees in the United States and France, offices in New York and Paris, 12,000+ orders completed. Also link building, enterprise SEO packages and white label for agencies.
- Honest fit. We suit businesses that want a fixed monthly package and visibility in AI answers as well as Google. If you want a large content or paid media team in the same contract, compare the full-service agencies below.
All 16 SEO agencies in New York compared
16 agencies
| # | Agency | Best for | Clutch | Budget | Based in |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Rankstar Our agency | SEO, AEO & GEO, Autosuggest, reputation | — | From €480/month12,000+ orders since 2018 | New York · Paris |
| 2 | DiscoverMyBusinessdiscovermybusiness.co | SEO plus reputation management | ★ 5.0137 reviews | Min. $1,000+$150–$199/hr | New York |
| 3 | Bird Marketingbird.marketing | Reviewed SEO at mid-level budgets | ★ 5.075 reviews | Min. $5,000+$100–$149/hr | New York |
| 4 | Web Tonicwebtonic.io | SEO/GEO plus paid media | ★ 5.057 reviews | Min. $5,000+$100–$149/hr | New York |
| 5 | OpenMovesopenmoves.com | Paid media plus SEO, eCommerce | ★ 5.052 reviews | Min. $5,000+$100–$149/hr | Huntington |
| 6 | Siege Mediasiegemedia.com | Content-led SEO and digital PR | ★ 4.948 reviews | Min. $5,000+$100–$149/hr | New York (office) |
| 7 | Sure Oaksureoak.com | Strategist-led SEO and AI search | ★ 4.944 reviews | Min. $5,000+$150–$199/hr | Brooklyn |
| 8 | Minty Digitalmintydigital.com | Smaller budgets, NYC team | ★ 4.831 reviews | Min. $1,000+$100–$149/hr | New York |
| 9 | Razor Rankrazorrank.com | Westchester SEO, low minimums | ★ 4.928 reviews | Min. $1,000+$100–$149/hr | Yonkers |
| 10 | Online Optimismonlineoptimism.com | Full-service digital, NYC office | ★ 5.018 reviews | Min. $1,000+$100–$149/hr | New York (office) |
| 11 | MeanPug Digitalmeanpug.com | Advertising channels plus SEO | ★ 5.010 reviews | Min. $10,000+$100–$149/hr | New York |
| 12 | BusySeedbusyseed.com | Lead-generation growth work | No profile | Custom quotes— | New York |
| 13 | iPullRankipullrank.com | Enterprise technical and AI search | No profile | — | New York (office) |
| 14 | Lounge Lizardloungelizard.com | Web build plus SEO | No profile | — | New York |
| 15 | Mimvimimvi.com | Local SEO from about $1,000/month | No profile | Site minimum $1,000/month3-month commitment | New York |
| 16 | Ironpaperironpaper.com | B2B growth, not pure SEO | No profile | — | New York |
No agency matches.
Clutch ratings, reviews, minimum project and hourly rates as shown on Clutch in November 2026 (in the currency Clutch shows). Rankstar is our agency.
The agencies in detail
2. DiscoverMyBusiness
DiscoverMyBusiness (discovermybusiness.co) is based at 261 Madison Ave in New York and was founded in 2018. Clutch lists 10–49 employees, 5.0 from 137 reviews, a $1,000+ minimum and $150–$199 an hour. It lists SEO including AI search, paid media, eCommerce, web design, CRO and online reputation management. Its site says retainers are mostly $2,000–$25,000 a month. It suits brands that want SEO and reputation work from one agency.
3. Bird Marketing
Bird Marketing (bird.marketing) is listed in New York, NY on Clutch, which shows 10–49 employees. It offers SEO and generative engine optimisation. Clutch shows 5.0 from 75 reviews, a $5,000+ minimum and $100–$149 an hour. Its site returned a 403 to our checker, but the Clutch profile is current. It suits companies that want reviewed SEO at a mid-level budget.
4. Web Tonic
Web Tonic (webtonic.io) is listed in New York, NY on Clutch, with 50–249 employees. It covers SEO and GEO, PPC, paid social, performance creative, tracking and web development. Clutch shows 5.0 from 57 reviews, a $5,000+ minimum and $100–$149 an hour. It suits performance marketing teams that want SEO and GEO next to paid media. It also publishes its own ranking of agencies; we did not use it.
5. OpenMoves
OpenMoves (openmoves.com) is listed in Huntington, NY on Clutch, which shows 50–249 employees. Its own site shows an Austin, Texas address, so the New York location rests on Clutch only. It covers paid media, technical, local and eCommerce SEO, CRO and email. Clutch shows 5.0 from 52 reviews, a $5,000+ minimum and $100–$149 an hour. It suits eCommerce and lead generation brands that want paid media with SEO.
6. Siege Media
Siege Media (siegemedia.com) has a New York office; its site lists Austin, Texas first, so we do not call it a New York headquarters. It offers GEO, SEO consulting, digital PR, content marketing and Reddit marketing. Clutch lists 50–249 employees, 4.9 from 48 reviews, a $5,000+ minimum and $100–$149 an hour. It suits teams that want content-led SEO and digital PR.
7. Sure Oak
Sure Oak (sureoak.com) is based at 77 Sands Street in Brooklyn. Clutch lists 10–49 employees, 4.9 from 44 reviews, a $5,000+ minimum and $150–$199 an hour. It lists SEO, GEO and AI search, link building, digital PR and content. It suits companies that want a strategist-led SEO and AI search programme and can meet a $5,000 minimum.
8. Minty Digital
Minty Digital (mintydigital.com) is listed in New York, NY, with 10–49 employees on Clutch. Clutch describes SEO and digital marketing, 4.8 from 31 reviews, a $1,000+ minimum and $100–$149 an hour. Its site returned a 403 to our checker, but the Clutch profile is current. It suits smaller budgets that want a New York team.
9. Razor Rank
Razor Rank (razorrank.com) is listed in Yonkers, NY, with 50–249 employees on Clutch. Clutch shows SEO, 4.9 from 28 reviews, a $1,000+ minimum and $100–$149 an hour. Its site returned a 403 to our checker, but the Clutch profile is current. It suits Westchester-area businesses that want SEO at a lower minimum.
10. Online Optimism
Online Optimism (onlineoptimism.com) was founded in 2012. Its headquarters is in New Orleans; it has a New York office at 157 Columbus Ave. It lists AEO and SEO, social, Google Ads, content, web design, video and branding. Clutch lists 10–49 employees, 5.0 from 18 reviews, a $1,000+ minimum and $100–$149 an hour. It suits businesses that want full-service digital work with a New York office.
11. MeanPug Digital
MeanPug Digital (meanpug.com) was founded in 2020 and is based at 280 Madison Ave in New York. Its team page shows 39 people; Clutch lists 10–49. It offers SEO, GEO, PPC, CTV and OTT advertising, Local Services Ads, content and web design. Clutch shows 5.0 from 10 reviews, a $10,000+ minimum and $100–$149 an hour. It suits brands that want several advertising channels plus SEO.
12. BusySeed
BusySeed (busyseed.com) was founded in 2013 and is based at 1178 Broadway in New York. It lists SEO, AI search and GEO, paid ads, social, email outreach, CRO and web design. We found no Clutch profile in our research, and its work is quoted case by case. It suits businesses focused on lead generation.
13. iPullRank
iPullRank (ipullrank.com) mentions a New York office; its site gives no address. The About page profiles 32 team members. It lists GEO and AI search, technical SEO, content engineering and relevance engineering. We found no Clutch profile in our research. It suits enterprise teams with technical and AI search needs.
14. Lounge Lizard
Lounge Lizard (loungelizard.com) was founded in 1998. It has an office at 112 West 34th Street in New York and a Long Island location. It lists web design and development, SEO and AEO/GEO, PPC, social, content and email. We found no Clutch profile in our research. It suits companies that want a website build and SEO from one agency.
15. Mimvi
Mimvi (mimvi.com) is based at 375 Park Ave in New York. It lists SEO, AI SEO and GEO, local SEO, web design and PPC. Its site recommends at least $1,000 a month with a 3-month commitment. We found no Clutch profile in our research. It suits small local businesses that want a stated entry price.
16. Ironpaper
Ironpaper (ironpaper.com) was founded in 2003 and is based at 10 East 33rd Street in New York. Its site says about 70 people work there. It lists B2B marketing, growth strategy, lead generation, account-based marketing, sales enablement and web work, not SEO as a standalone service. We found no Clutch profile in our research. It suits B2B companies that want a growth agency, not a pure SEO one.
SEO in New York: what to know in 2027
We found no New York State search-share figures, so these are US figures. StatCounter, October 2026, all platforms: Google 85.45%, Bing 9.78%, Yahoo 2.54%, DuckDuckGo 1.74%, Yandex 0.32%, Ecosia 0.11%. Source: StatCounter, United States.
The practical point: optimise for Google first, and treat Bing as a second channel worth about one search in ten. We did not verify state-level language, consent or licensing rules, so we state none here.
Competition in New York is high. Clutch shows about 40 pages of SEO firms for New York, and the top results for this keyword are directories and agency-written lists that rank their own publisher. Ask any agency for clients in your sector, and for named people on the account.
AEO and GEO in New York
AEO (answer engine optimisation) shapes pages so search features and assistants can quote them. GEO (generative engine optimisation) aims to get your brand cited in AI answers. We found no verified New York usage figures for AI assistants, so we give none. Of the 15 agencies above, 11 name GEO, AI search or AEO among their services.
Online reputation management in New York
We could not verify a New York law that lets you demand removal of a search result. Bills proposed in 2017 (S4561 and A5323) would have required removal of some information; we could not confirm their status from the official site. Ask a local lawyer about your case.
US federal law matters too. Under 47 U.S.C. 230(c)(1) (Cornell LII), online providers cannot be treated as the publisher of content others created. Google also has its own personal information removal policy, which covers items such as contact details, government ID numbers and bank or card numbers.
Rankstar offers removal of negative Google suggestions, usually gone in 10–20 days, and reputation management plans.
How much does an SEO agency cost in New York?
We found no New York-specific price survey. These are the sourced figures, with whose they are.
| Figure | Whose | Value |
|---|---|---|
| Hourly rates of New York agencies | Clutch listings, provider-reported | Under $25 to $200–$300; typical $100–$149 |
| Minimum projects of New York agencies | Clutch listings, provider-reported | $1,000+ to $75,000+ |
| DiscoverMyBusiness retainers | The agency's own site | Mostly $2,000–$25,000 a month |
| Mimvi recommended minimum | The agency's own site | $1,000 a month, 3-month commitment |
Rankstar's public prices: SEO · AEO · GEO packages and local packages from €480 a month. Google Autosuggest from €590 a month for 3 keywords. Every item is listed on the price pages.
How to choose an SEO agency in New York
Check these before you sign:
- Confirm the address. Several agencies on directories list New York but have no office there; we removed some for that reason.
- Ask which office does the work. A New York office can be a satellite of an agency based elsewhere.
- Compare the minimum project with your budget. New York minimums on Clutch run from $1,000+ to $75,000+.
- Ask for a price list or scope in writing, not a quote after a sales call.
- Ask what they do for AEO and GEO, and how they measure it.
- Check reviews on more than one source, and ask to speak to a client in your sector.
- Ask who owns the content, accounts and data if you leave.
Red flags:
- A guaranteed #1 ranking.
- A long lock-in with no exit terms.
- A "best agency" list where the publisher ranks itself first, without saying so.
- No named people or case work you can check.
- Prices hidden until a call, with no range given.











